Neil Young had it right—only love can break your heart. There’s no feeling like heartbreak and it sucks any time of the year…but when Valentine’s Day rolls around (with all the flowers and chocolate and heart-shaped Tums) it’s practically unbearable. So, for those who’ll spend the 14th all by their lonesome, I’ve compiled my top 5 list of the unrequited love songs. Turn ‘em up, sing along, and let it out. President’s Day will be here before you know it.
1. Bob Dylan – “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright”
Bob Dylan is the king of unrequited love songs, at least in the rock and pop world. When he went through a nasty divorce in the mid-‘70s, the man wrote an entire album of them (1975’s Blood on the Tracks). Still, this one is his best. Recorded for The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan and written about the girl that appears on the front cover of the album with him, this song finds Bob acting indifferent. His words betray him. Deep down he’s bitter, he’s hurt, and he’s leaving.
2. The Rolling Stones – “Love In Vain”
I had to include at least one blues tune. Written by Robert Johnson (you know, the one who sold his soul to the devil at the crossroads), “Love in Vain” is chock-full of loneliness and heartbreak…like all good blues songs. Add to that Mick Jagger’s vocals and Keith Richard’s serpentine slide guitar and you’ve got rock and roll gold.
3. Derek and the Dominoes – “Layla”
Everybody knows the song, but I doubt many know the story behind it. George Harrison was married to model and photographer Pattie Boyd, and Eric Clapton fell in love with her. Clapton, a good friend of Harrison’s, stole a name from a Middle Eastern folk tale about two lovers kept apart by another man (in the story, the girl’s father) and proceeded to dedicate an entire album to his “Layla.” Clapton eventually got the girl, though…and George was the best man at the wedding.
4. The Band – “It Makes No Difference”
“It Makes No Difference” breaks my heart every time I listen to it. The Band was blessed with three killer lead singers: pianist Richard Manuel (my personal favorite), drummer Levon Helm, and bassist Rick Danko. Danko takes the majority of vocal duties on this one, and his trademark warble lends a desperation to this song that is unsurpassed. In a world of Avril Lavine, Shania Twain, and Nickelback, it’s sometimes difficult to remember that Canada once produced good music.
5. Hank Williams – “Half as Much”
And what would a list of unrequited love songs be without at least one country song? Incomplete, that’s what. I almost picked the Hank Williams song about the wooden Indian that pines for another inanimate Native American…but come on, aren’t we all tired of hearing that same old story? This Curely Williams song has been covered tons of times in a bunch of different ways, but the original performance is the definitive one. Order another round and put this one on.